I’m going to level with you, guys.
I’m halfway through a day out in London working on my Google Pixel 7 review and I really, really want to frisbee my 16-inch MacBook Pro into the River Thames.
I’ll level with you again. That laptop isn’t the only thing in my backpack. I also have a Sony FX3 camera, mini tripod, iPad Air with Magic Keyboard, a change of clothes and a bunch of charging cables.
However, combined, this stuff isn’t actually that heavy. The FX3 is one of the lightest full-frame ‘cinema’ cameras on the market, the mini tripod is barely there, and the iPad Air isn’t what I’d call a beast. But when you combine that lot with the 16-inch MacBook Pro, boy is it a heavy backpack.
So heavy, in fact, that I’m reconsidering my laptop choices going forward.
The London backbreaker
I’m starting to undertake more travel for the Mark Ellis Reviews channel. Whether it’s heading to London to put some real effort into a smartphone review or jumping on a plane to Amsterdam next week for a day out with JBL, I’m finally breaking free of the studio.
I love travelling and feel very fortunate to combine it with a job I love just as much. The challenge, however, is the tech I end up taking with me; it always feels like I’m overdoing it.
I’m often filming myself while travelling and I’m a bit of a camera snob, hence the presence of the FX3 rather than relying on my smartphone. I also write while on the road (as I’m doing now in a lovely coffee shop in the centre of London’s financial district), so a convenient writing tool needs to accompany me, too.
With so many videos being worked on (often concurrently) I also need to be able to dive into edits here and there, which is where the 16-inch MacBook Pro comes in. And where all the problems start.
I went for the big boy MacBook mainly because of that screen, which remains utterly wonderful for on-the-go editing. There’s just a serious trade-off when it comes to portability.
I’ve been informed by certain cretinous YouTube commenters that I need to “go to the gym” if I think this laptop is heavy. Trust me, when you’ve spent all day walking around with this thing glued to your back, it’s anything but light – gym or no gym.
It’s also inconveniently huge when attempting to dig into an edit at venues with smaller tables or while travelling in normal-class train carriages.
The 16-inch MacBook Pro is a massive computer. End of story.
The sheer size of the thing also makes it incredibly inconvenient for on-the-go writing, hence the inclusion of the iPad Air in my backpack.
So, where do we go from here?
The alternative
I should reiterate that I think the 16-inch MacBook Pro is a wonderful laptop. Mine is more powerful than I need it to be, which provides wonderful peace of mind for a return on investment over multiple years of use.
However, I spent some time with the 14-inch version last year, and I often think about its ‘sling-under-the-arm’ convenience. Sure, it doesn’t have the expansive 16-inch screen, but you can place it on most tables and use it to bash out a few hundred words wherever you happen to be.
The timing of this revelation is rather convenient. We’re approaching (possibly) a bunch of new Mac releases from Apple, one of which is likely to be a new M2-powered MacBook Pro.
I’ll be checking these new devices out for review purposes, but with my back sweating from lugging around my beastly 16-inch (laptop) today, I’m wondering if it’s time to cut ties and make the switch.
What are the downsides of doing so? That return on investment takes a hit, and I lose the bigger screen. Although, at the moment – and with the Thames in clear view – I’m willing to make those sacrifices.
Final Cut Pro. On the iPad. PLEASE.
This conundrum has reignited a desire I’ve had for a long time, which is to witness the appearance of Final Cut Pro on the iPad Pro.
This would solve all of my issues. With that option in my backpack, I’d only have needed to bring my iPad Pro with me to London this week, which would have saved all kinds of back problems in later life.
As I’ve noted previously, there are a couple of non-negotiables if Apple is indeed working on an iPadOS version of Final Cut Pro. Firstly, it needs to be the full version with absolutely no corners cut at all. If they skimp on features in any area, it’s a no-go, immediately; I need to switch seamlessly between edits on the Mac and iPad.
Secondly, the transition between operating systems on Final Cut Pro can’t be a heavy lift. This is a tricky problem to solve, I know – Final Cut Pro library files get unreasonably large and cumbersome, therefore the thought of somehow synchronising them between devices is rather unpalatable.
These are challenges I’m sure Apple is working on and I remain hopeful that we’ll see Final Cut Pro on the iPad Pro.
Or maybe I’m living in Cloud Cuckoo Land.
Final thought
I’m curious – if you’re the current owner of a 16-inch MacBook Pro, do you regret the decision at all? Have you encountered similar back-breaking days as I have?
If that’s the case, are you eyeing up the 14-inch version for your next laptop? Or am I overreacting here?
Get involved in the comments!
I’m using the 2022 13″ MacBook Pro. I use it for work and to run my YouTube channel, and if I’m honest, I love it! For me the 13″ is the perfect size. I’d happily use the 14″ too. I’ve never been a fan of the 15/16″ laptops. I get why many people love them. But for me portability is hugely important. I don’t think you’ll have long to wait before there’s a new 14″ MacBook Pro to review. You’ll have plenty of excuses to get one, and even MORE excuses to ignore those cretins!!
Haha – very true, Ronan!
The 14 inch MacBook Pro is perfect for me, even though I also load my Dell work laptop into my backpack every day. Yes, I have two laptops that I have to lug around and when I travel, I also add an iPad Pro 11inch with Magic Keyboard and AirPods Max to the backpack and I somehow survive.
I have had similar thoughts Mark. I used a 13″ Macbook Retina for a long time and loved the lightness, portability and utility. The 15″ MBP was at the limit of portability for me. I now leave the 16″ MBP in my home office and use an iPad Pro while mobile. Its a different interface, but I’m now fully productive on the iPad
Hi, new to your site and the first article I’ve read. I love my 2019 15″ MBP – but am looking forward to a 15 or 16″ M2 Air… something I never thought would happen. But since I don’t use final cut pro or do video editing, just a bit of gaming occasionally I think it’ll be the right choice! I couldn’t make a go of it with an ipad, a bridge too far for me, but I look forward to reading if final cut appears on ipad for you!
I don’t use my MBP 14in for travel, but when I bought it, one of my considerations was that if I needed to take my home office with me anytime, using this as my home office device would be the way to go. In that respect, I don’t regret it. It means I can go visit friends for an extended holiday but still handle any work requests easily. I feel it’s heavy enough. I can’t imagine lugging around it with the other equipment you carry, but you’re not a 61yr old with health issues so you’d likely manage just fine.
The boring answer is i fully agree. basically because at home i’m using the 32inch ThinkVision monitor (usb-c) anyhow and i keep the lid closed. Another mistake i made is going for the I9 at that time. For my use (largely web app dev) it’s total overkill and hurts my battery life. Portability and battery life is much more important.
I totally agree with you, Mark. I’m leaning towards a 13/14” laptop with my next upgrade.
I did value my 15” screen size when I was at uni using it a lot without an external monitor but since I mostly use it docked or when I travel to clients now, the increase in portability is better for my new use case.
In my opinion, what size you go for depends on A) what you’re doing and B) how you’re doing it. If you’re a video editor/games developer etc., planning to use your laptop primarily just with its own screen then 15/16” could make sense. If you plan on docked it to an external monitor or value portability and don’t need the extra screen then 13/14” is better.