We may earn compensation from reviewed products. Learn about our editorial policies.
My YouTube channel is pretty much self-funded.
I say “pretty much”, because I do get sent the odd review unit. And sometimes, they really are odd.
When it comes to Apple stuff, however, I have no choice but to buy the stuff they release myself. There’s a simple reason for this: Apple only knows I exist because of my credit card number. I’m some way off ever receiving review units from Cupertino HQ.
However, despite this, it’s rare that I have to convince myself to invest in one of their products – AirPods Max aside.
A case in point: I’ve thought long and hard about the M1 iPad Pro that was launched at the Spring Loaded event earlier this year, and I cannot think of a single reason why it might be worth my or my audience’s time.
I wish this wasn’t the case.
Let’s not beat around the bush: WWDC21 was a let down
The majority of the announcements made at this year’s WWDC keynote were either a) “well, that makes total sense”, or, b) “why on earth didn’t I think of that?!”.
macOS Monterey is effectively a point release featuring an absolute showstopper in Universal Control, and iOS 15 packs in enough nice-to-haves and mini surprises to make it worth getting excited about.
But iPadOS. Oh, Tim.
The headline on Apple’s preview page for iPadOS 15 tells us that we’ll soon be able to take our iPad’s versatility even further. Great! Only, as far as Apple is concerned, that means slightly better multitasking, widgets, quick notes, FaceTime updates, focus modes, and a few other minor updates to apps like Safari and Maps.
Scroll down to the bottom of the page, and the list of devices with which iPadOS 15 is compatible is colossal. It goes right down to the iPad Air 2.
What’s missing is a bit at the top which says “feature X only available on M1 iPad Pro”.
My YouTube comments said it all
“Wait until WWDC.”
“You’ve got this all wrong. Sure, it’s the same iPad now, but wait until WWDC.”
“I bought this iPad because I know what’s coming at WWDC.”
“Just you wait until June – big things are coming to the iPad.”
“Everyone who’s laughing at the M1 iPad will be laughing on the other sides of their faces when WWDC takes place.”
A bit like the massive hardware leak fail for WWDC this year, the expectations for some kind of huge update to iPadOS that would unleash the power of the M1 chip were completely quashed.
Nothing happened. I don’t think the M1 iPad Pro was even mentioned during the keynote.
There was a glimmer of hope during the demo for macOS Monterey’s brilliant Universal Control feature. This enables users to share the same input devices between Macs and iPads. Craig Federighi showed it off by dragging an image from an iPad, needlessly passing it through a MacBook and finally dropping it into a Final Cut Pro timeline on an iMac.
Perhaps, we all collectively thought, this means that the M1 iPad will be able to run macOS apps in some kind of extended way. Maybe Universal Control is only compatible with the new iPad Pro!
Nope. It even works on the third-generation iPad Air and fifth-generation iPad mini.
This was yet another minor, mildly iterative release for iPadOS – nothing more. Whatever it was that we were all waiting for simply didn’t materialise.
How I use my 2018 iPad Pro (it’s enough)
When I switched to the brilliant iPad Air 4, my 2018 12.9″ iPad Pro was almost put out to pasture.
I couldn’t think of a reason to use it, thanks to the Air’s far more comfortable size and blistering pace.
Then, I watched Peter McKinnon use the latest iPad Pro to edit photos and I decided to copy him. I do that a lot.
So, my 2018 iPad Pro is now my photo editing tool, and I absolutely love it. Why I didn’t do this earlier is anyone’s guess, but it has revitalised my photo editing; I enjoy it far more now that I’m using the iPad.
But it doesn’t feel like I’m pushing the 2018 iPad Pro when using Lightroom at all. It breezes through the workflow I’ve adopted for editing my RAW photos.
So, there’s still no need for me to buy that M1 iPad Pro, is there?
What I want
I’ve thought about this a lot.
I’d love to review the iPad Pro and use it in some way to boost my productivity and efficiency.
But, at the moment, it isn’t giving me a reason to do so. The review would be the shortest and most boring I’ve ever made (“here’s the new one – it feels the same as the old one”), and I already have an iPad Pro that’s faster than I need it to be.
One of the most taxing tasks I undertake is video editing. It’s hard work for both the computer on which I edit, and my brain (although it is deeply enjoyable). However, since I sold my 16″ MacBook Pro, I’m bound to one computer for video editing, which is the brilliant M1 Mac mini. That means I have to always undertake this vital part of my business at one desk.
I spend lots of time working either in coffee shops or on my sofa, and I miss the days when I could edit my videos on a portable device.
That’s why I would place an order right now for an M1 iPad Pro if it enabled me to do this, via Final Cut Pro, and seamlessly transfer the workflow back to the Mac mini whenever I needed to. That would be game-changing.
But it feels like a long way off.
What do you want?
There are two Apple products I’ve written about this year that have attracted more attention than even the M1 chip – the Apple TV and the M1 iPad Pro.
I suspect, therefore, that if you’ve got this far, you’ve probably got plenty of thoughts about it yourself. So, let me know what you’re expecting from the M1 iPad Pro. Were you disappointed by WWDC? Or am I completely missing the point?
Get involved in the comments!
8 Comments
Hey Mark,
So I own a 2020 11” iPad Pro (+magic keyboard), purchased in June last year. I was anxious for the 2021 iPad Pro release with all the great features, mini LED and at release that M1 Chip! I thought, oh no I should have waited, can I afford to trade in my 2020 and get the 2021?!
I waited and feverishly watched every M1 iPad Pro video that I could find and slowly began to realise that maybe the M1 isn’t as great a device as I first thought it would be? It’s fast, yeah, but like you I find my 2020 to be plenty fast for my casual workflow. Mini LED, awesome! But it’s limited to the 12.9” and oh wait it’s super expensive.
Then I thought, hang on, all this power and then WWDC is right around the corner. All the YouTubers are right, pro apps and exclusive features are coming to M1 iPad Pro, that will definitely give a point of difference. Aaaaannnnddddd nothing… WWDC both disappointed & gratified me. I felt disappointed that Apple hadn’t done anything amazing with the power of the M1 but also relieved that my 2020 would still be at the pinnacle of iPadOS and I wouldn’t have any need to buy the new M1.
From a Sales & Marketing perspective, I believe it would be commercial suicide to bring MacOS to iPad Pro and maybe pro apps is the first step towards a true MacBook replacement, which I am sure that Apple doesn’t actually want to bring to reality. Following dub dub, I still believe the M1 to be no functionally different to my 2020 & your 2018, they are still crazy fast, highly portable and better than anything else out there.
What this means however, is that I have convinced myself to buy an M1 MacBook Pro to gain access to those functional differences, so I guess Apple will get my money anyway. But I think this is their plan all along, for users to own an iPad as well as a MacBook and really lock you into that ecosystem that is too convenient to move away from. Oh and I can use both for Universal Control, that’s convenient!
If I was you, I wouldn’t buy the M1 iPad Pro. From a personal perspective if the 2018 is plenty fast for you and you don’t need the mini LED display, stick with what you have, it’s too expensive to really feel the benefit. Like you say, it’s your own cash you would be spending. From a professional perspective, every Tom, Dick & Harry has posted an M1 iPad Pro video. While I have no doubt that an M1 video would drive traffic to your channel (maybe that’s reason enough?), all the videos I watched are essentially exactly the same.
This is just my humble thoughts from an Apple fanboy who has no experience of YouTube or the dreaded algorithm.
I’m really enjoying your down to earth YouTube style, it’s also refreshing to get a British perspective on these things. Let’s be honest, we are not the same consumer that others around the world are!
Keep up the great work!
Cheers,
Will
Thank you, Will (and for your kind thoughts). Lots to mull over there!
‘Great Expectations’
Goodness, I’ve rarely felt so torn over a new device.
For weeks before WWDC21 I was enjoying the anticipation of my great expectations for iPadOS 15 on the new M1 iPad Pro. And it all made sense! The specifications for the M1 were more or less leaked and those on YouTube far more technically minded than me ranged from the most confident claiming that Apple Pro Apps such as Final Cut Pro, Logic, and even XCode were coming to the iPad Pro to others slightly more cautious at least asking the question “Could pro apps be coming to the iPad Pro?”
But, with the benefit of hindsight, both my great Expectations and personal circumstances were too good to be true. Picture this if you will. After what was arguably obsessive examination and consideration, I had over several months forensically selected and purchased the perfect accessories and some peripherals in preparation for acquisition of my new maxed-out M1 12.9″ – and I don’t mean “maxed-out except for…” No. I mean maxed out! To add even further curiosity to this extravagance, the device would not only have been my very first tablet, but would actually be my very first Apple device. Pure “virgin idealism” in both mind and action so to speak.
And then, it didn’t happen. WWDC21 systematically and tediously tore apart my hopes over 1Hr. 45mins. of iterations. I write “hopes” and “iterations” to employ some polite euphemisms. The brutal reality was I was really focused on ONE singular set of updates to iPadOS15 which was the arrival of Pro apps on the M1 iPad Pro. “It has everything else in place”, I trustingly believed. What I was not expecting from the new software was the addition of a collection of nice haves and gimmicks. Forgive my bluntness. I am reliving the bitter disappointment.
So, where does that leave me now? Well, to add irony to the insult, (or salt to the wounds if you prefer), I’m one of those individuals who was not momentarily side-tracked by rumours of possible new Hardware making an appearance at WWDC21. And for once in my life, I wasn’t interested in new Hardware. It wasn’t my focus. The fabled M1X MacBook Pro for example was clearly a red herring from even the most cursory of glances through MacRumors or 9-5Mac. Notes from trusted sources who heard very reliable whispers from Supply Chain sources knew that production of such machines was no where ready for a public announcement. And writing of Hardware, reliable if somewhat preliminary predictions regarding the next iPad Pro with mentions of Magsafe and reverse charging doesn’t leave me overflowing with enthusiasm. In fact, it creates for me somewhat of a dilemma. Should I purchase the M1 iPad Pro now to be complimented by all those lovely accessories I so carefully chose? Or should I wait for the next iPad Pro which I may well not like at all?
But, perhaps most ironic of all for me in my “virgin idealism” was I am also one of those individuals who wants to edit videos using both an iPad Pro and MacBook Pro. Continuity between those chosen devices for my particular workflow. I am not interested in MacOS on iPads or any such machinations because I simply accept those who repeatedly say, “it would not work.” But, I would over the next couple of years love to purchase a top-spec iPad Pro and Macbook Pro as my piggy bank will allow. Does that not resemble what Apple would like to see us doing as customers?
Well, there you have it. I guess it sounds a bit like the classic love/hate relationship so many experience with one of the most profitable companies in the World today. But, as a guy now in his early 50’s, I don’t want to invest too much time in the “masochistic” pleasures of will apple give me or deny me? I just want to enjoy some of the finer things in life like beautifully designed and engineered consumer technology with a reputation for getting the job done.
Pingback: How I Use Three M1 Macs - Mark Ellis Reviews
Pingback: iPad mini 6 vs iPad Air 4: Which Is Better? - Mark Ellis Reviews
Apple has shown that the M1 chip can run OSX right? Right?!?
We also know that OSX can run iPhone/iPad apps right?
So functionally speaking there is no reason at all why apple couldn’t give us an iPad hooked up to a keyboard and mouse to actually run OSX.
That is exactly what I want, and I am sure that Apple can technically deliver if they were so included. I want my iPad to also be my MacBook Air, so to speak. If apple is concerned about the experience and functionality fine… give me a Mac mode and an iPad mode. When I hook up to a magic keyboard allow me to use the M1 iPad like I would a MacBook Air. After all what is the real difference between the two in that configuration? Heck, do allow me to also use the touch screen.
When detected from the magic keyboard then revert to a app like interface. Lead by example by making OSX apps be able to switch to a touch interface like outline. Or design it to be universally versatile.
Either way, it annoys me that the iPad M1 has so much potential, but end of the day is basically an oversized iPhone on steroids.
Pingback: My Favourite Apple Product of 2021 - Mark Ellis Reviews
Pingback: Apple Mac Studio Reaction: Hello, Ludicrous Power - Mark Ellis Reviews